|
Film History
4, no. 3 (Spring 1991), 237-256.
Forty
Days Across America: Kiyooka Eiichi's 1927 Travelogues
In
the west, you couldn't tell from what the road looked like
ahead, what the damn road was going to look like when you
got beyond anything you could now see.
-Maxwell
Fisch.1
In the spring of
1989, I was recruited to read my younger brother's undergraduate
thesis, "The Making of a Moderate in Prewar Japan: Kiyooka Eiichi."
Knowing little about Japanese history and culture, I directed
my comments towards the style and organization of Kenneth's
argument. As I was reading one of several drafts, an intriguing
story caught my attention. As a young man studying in the United
States in the 1920s, Mr. Kiyooka drove a
Model T Ford across the country. On the way, he filmed his adventures
with a new Kodak 16mm movie camera. Although this story was
tangential to Kenneth's main focus on Kiyooka's life during
the rise of militarism in Japan in the 1930s, he nevertheless
noted that Kiyooka's films of the trip were frequently shown
to family and friends in Tokyo during that period. As a student
of film history and a devotee of amateur film, a footnote struck
my imagination, "Incredibly enough, Keiõ [University]
still has the film."2 My own interests in amateur
uses of the cinema suggested that these images from 1927 might
provide an exciting case study of home movies.
We wrote to Professor
Kiyooka to ask if he would be willing to lend us his films.
He offered to send them immediately and said that he would be
delighted to answer our questions about his experiences as a
student in America in the 1920s and especially about his 1927
cross-country automobile trip. With few assurances about the
quality and intrinsic value of his images, we paid several hundred
dollars to transfer the delicate original films to 1" videotape
at John E. Allen, Inc. in New Jersey, a commercial facility
that specializes in the preservation and sale of archival motion
pictures. The films looked promising and we made plans to interview
Professor Kiyooka later that
238
summer in Indianapolis, Indiana, where he intended to visit his
friend Maxwell Fisch.
This series of events
reminded me that individuals, guided by their own interests
and knowledge, set the agenda for historical research. Of course,
individual interests are also bound by institutional constraints
and support, professional certification, conventions of disciplines,
and the like. As a student in the Department of East Asian Studies
at Harvard University, Kenneth would not have been permitted
to write an honor's thesis about Kiyooka's home movies. At the
same time, his research would not have been possible without
a grant from the Reischauer Institute to travel to Tokyo to
interview Professor Kiyooka. What seemed an incidental detail
to my brother's research on notions of democracy in modern Japan
struck me as an exciting prospect for expanding the agenda of
film studies. Most film history still focuses on the dominant
practices of the fiction film industry. The history of home
movies and amateur uses of media have yet to be written although
traces exist in industry archives, trade journals, and family
attics. Kiyooka's films, moreover, fascinated me as a hybrid
form of home movie travelogues, shot in the U. S. by a young
man from a different culture. Unfortunately, the virtual absence
of case studies of home movies or travelogues make comparisons
with other amateurs impossible. All of my conclusions then will
necessarily be limited to a close analysis of Kiyooka's 16mm
films, writings, and recollections.
The materials of
this study include 29:45 minutes of 16mm reversal film of Kiyooka's
1927 trip across the United States. The original footage, although
in good condition, has shrunk to the point where the distance
between the sprocket holes is too small for normal projection.
For this reason, the footage was transferred to videotape to
allow for close analysis and repeated viewings. In 1928, Kiyooka
published a series of articles about his trip, "Across the United
States in a Model T Ford--1927," in the February, March, and
April 1928 issues of the Japanese periodical Mita Hyõron,
based on extensive diaries he kept during the trip. Kiyooka
brought a 1976 English translation of these articles to Indianapolis
in the summer of 1989.
While riding in the
back seat of his Model T Ford, as his friends Max and Ruth Fisch
were driving, Kiyooka periodically jotted down his impressions
of the landscape and kept a record of their activities on the
road. Unfortunately, the diaries and original manuscript were
destroyed during the American bombing of Tokyo in 1945. Nevertheless,
the published accounts are rich in detail and anecdote. Needless
to say, most of my information about Japan and, of course, about
Kiyooka Eiichi, comes from Kenneth J. Ruoff's thesis, "The Making
of a Moderate in Prewar Japan: Kiyooka Eiichi," based on interviews
conducted in June of 1988. This work places Kiyooka's life and
thought in the context of the growing militarism and anti-American
sentiment of the 1930s, sentiment that Kiyooka did not share.
In addition, eight hours of videotaped interviews with Professor
Kiyooka, focusing on the 1927 trip, were recorded in Indianapolis
in July of 1989. Even at 87 years of age, Kiyooka is an active,
energetic world traveller. As much as possible in this study,
I will have him speak in his own words about his experiences
in the United States.
Today, Kiyooka Eiichi
is a professor emeritus of English literature at Keiõ
University in Tokyo. Maxwell Fisch, his friend from Cornell
University, is a professor emeritus of philosophy at the University
of Indiana-Indianapolis. The 16mm film footage and the diaries
represent Kiyooka's reactions to and impressions of the American
landscape. The image of America in the films combines elements
of personal interests, standard tourist iconography, and an
outsider's perspective to present a unique vision of the American
landscape, a landscape dominated by the ubiquitous automobile.
For this upper-class Japanese gentleman, particular features
of the social landscape filled the notebooks and viewfinder:
the wide-open vistas of the prairie states; a rodeo in Prescott,
Arizona; the unpaved roads west of Kansas; Navajo Indians and
their homes in New Mexico; the island of Alcatraz in the San
Francisco Bay. Kiyooka's films and writings
provide traces of an earlier way of life, a moment when cameras
and cars, standardized products of mass production techniques,
collaborated to create an intimate and popular image of the
American landscape. As Warren Belasco suggests in Americans
on the Road: From Autocamp to Motel, 1910-1945, "Like another
recent invention, the motion picture, the automobile offered
unprecedented experiences of time, space, and movement."3
More than home movies, but less than a finished documentary
film, Kiyooka Eiichi's travelogues meander across an American
landscape both real and imagined, documented and interpreted
by a 25-year-old Japanese student on his way back home to his
native Tokyo.
In Americans on
the Road, Belasco reproduces a photograph of a celebrated
autocamping trip from 192l, "When President Warren G. Harding
joined Henry Ford, Thomas Edison, and Harvey Firestone on one
of their closely reported autocamping trips, it seemed that
everyone was doing it."4 Reported in contemporary
newsreels, photographs, and articles in Motorist and
Field and Stream, this celebrity excursion epitomizes
the development of the new consumer society made possible through
mass-production techniques. During the 1920s, for example, the
Ford Motor Company sold over one million Model T Fords per year.5
These pioneer industrialists of the automobile
239
and film industries, together with American politicians, innovated
new technologies and a new consumer ethic that millions of Americans
put into practice in the 1920s. Kiyooka's travelogues offer one
instance of these new technologies collaborating in their everyday
context.
In order to understand
Kiyooka's involvement with cameras and cars, we need to understand
his cultural background and certain aspects of modern Japanese
history. Ever since Commodore Perry insisted that the Tokugawa
Shogunate open its country to international trade, the United
States has been involved in a complex cultural exchange with
Japan. Seven years later, in 1860, the first Japanese diplomatic
mission sailed for San Francisco. When the Shogunate fell, the
reigh of Emperor Mutsuhito began, lasting from 1867 to 1912.
During this period, the Meiji era, or "enlightened peace," Japan
embarked on a process of rapid modernization and industrialization,
absorbing western science and technology. Enlightenment intellectuals
like Fukuzawa Yukichi, who had served as a clerk on the 1860
mission to the U. S., promoted democratic ideals and individual
rights through newspaper articles and best-selling books. This
cultural exchange, alternately imposed, welcomed, rejected,
and enforced, has continued throughout the twentieth century,
with the American occupation of Japan from 1945-52, marking
the period of most direct influence.
Japanese students
first started coming to American universities in 1872, the year
of the first overseas mission of the Meiji government. Tadashi
Aruga notes the beginning of this process in his discussion
of the first Japanese mission to the U. S. in Abroad in America:
Visitors to the New Nation:
The Kanrin Maru
group also produced a foremost educator, journalist, and champion
of enlightenment in Meiji Japan--Fukuzawa Yukichi. As a young
student of western languages and science, Fukuzawa had volunteered
to serve as a clerk of Admiral Kimura in order to see America.
Because of his knowledge, he
240
was not surprised
by scientific and industrial devices he saw there. But he
experienced a series of shocks in "matters of life and social
custom and ways of thinking." Although he was able to visit
only California, that was enough to make him aware of the
blessings of a progressive, democratic society. His later
trips to America and Europe reinforced his conviction. He
opened a school named Keiõ Gijiku (which later became
a university), wrote many enlightening books, and founded
a newspaper. Paraphrasing a passage of the American Declaration
of Independence, Fukuzawa began his widely read series of
essays, An Encouragement of Learning, with this message:
"It is said that heaven did not create one man above or below
another man." He never entered the bureaucracy of the Meiji
government, cherishing his liberty as an independent citizen.
"Proud and independent" was the motto he gave to his students.
Among the Japanese visitors of 1860, it was Fukuzawa who had
learned most from American democracy.6
More than any other
individual in the Meiji era, Fukuzawa exposed the Japanese people
to the culture of the west through such popular books as Things
Western and The Autobiography of Fukuzawa, and through
his newspaper, Jiji Shimpõ. Fukuzawa's sons and
grandsons, together with other members of the westernized elite
in Japan, were sent to study abroad in the United States and
Europe. The history of modern Japan is the history of an intense
engagement with the values, technology, ideas, and material
culture of the western world. Kiyooka Eiichi himself is a product
of this ongoing cultural exchange between Japan and the United
States.
A grandson of the
great Fukuzawa Yukichi, and a member of the intelligentsia in
Tokyo, Kiyooka grew up steeped in the culture of the western
world. He already had an English tutor in his home before he
began his formal schooling at age six. Members of his family
helped introduce golf to Japan; new technological inventions
like the telephone appeared early in Kiyooka's home. His mother
converted to Christianity when he was a young boy, and his older
sister attended the Sacred Heart School,
one of the only secondary schools willing to educate Japanese
girls. When Kiyooka started school, he went to the Keiõ
Primary School, founded in 1858 by Fukuzawa to promote understanding
of western knowledge. In addition, Kiyooka was eventually baptised
in the Anglican Church at the age of sixteen. Having graduated
high school, he dreamed of becoming a mechanical engineer.7
When he was seventeen, his parents decided that he should go
to study abroad in America. Kiyooka still marvels at his parents'
brash decision to send him to study abroad for seven years:
My going to Ithaca
was decided because my cousin was there, but just going was
the only thing that was decided and certain. Just who was
going to take care of me and where I was going to settle in
Ithaca was not exactly understood, and my parents didn't seem
to care. That's something that even now I don't understand.
They simply believed in the advanced civilization of the United
States, I suppose.8
In July, 1920, Kiyooka
travelled by boat from Yokohama to Seattle, a journey that took
two weeks. From San Francisco, he proceeded by train across
the country to New York City in the company of a Japanese scholar
who knew his family. Kiyooka's education, travels, diaries,
and films all reflect the profound influence of his grandfather,
Fukuzawa; all of Kiyooka's work has been done in his spirit.
Studying at Cornell
University in Ithaca, New York, Kiyooka hoped to be an engineer,
a career embracing the industrial technology of the United States.
Having failed his mathematics examinations, however, Kiyooka
shifted gears and decided to study America. To his surprise,
he was unable to take courses in either American history or
American literature; both subjects were considered subsets of
other disciplines:
At that time--well,
young people won't know those old days--there was no such
thing as American literature at that time and nothing in
American literature was offered in Cornell University. Just
one course on the history of American literature. The professor
explained that there was nothing worthwhile in American literature
that should be in the university. The literature was the early
literature of colonial times. In 1920s, you know, American
people didn't think too much of America itself. American literature
was considered one branch of English literature.9
Coming from a family
that "worshipped" American culture, Kiyooka was astonished to
find few courses about the culture of the United States. In
Kiyooka's mind, this indicated that America was a young country
at the time.
In 1925, Kiyooka
purchased a Model T Ford for one hundred dollars. The previous
owner of the car showed him how to drive, "When I purchased
this second-hand car, the man who owned the garage offered to
teach me how to drive it, and we drove around the country roads
for one day. Just one day's instruction from the man who sold
me the car, that was enough for me."10 He
used the car for Sunday excursions and to visit the eastern
states during vacation breaks from school. Kiyooka's background
gave him ample familiarity with the mores and material culture
of American society. He seized on the details that made the
mass-produced Model T Ford an exciting automobile:
241
The cars of those
days were so simple, engine was simple too. An amateur could
go at it without too much difficulty. I was very fond of machinery
and it came out all right. What I did was to take off the
top and scrape the carbon off the top and change the valves.
Today I suppose the owners of their cars
don't overhaul their cars. In those days, overhauling a car
was a part of the fun, part of the fun of having a car. In
Japan, cars were luxury things, rather than everyday toy of
car lovers. This trip of mine was just about the last car
pleasure of mine, when I reached home, why my father had a
car, but a luxurious, beautiful car that I won't dare touch.11
Kiyooka reiterates
the features that made the Model T Ford a commercial success.
Through the techniques of mass production, Henry Ford and the
Ford Motor Company managed to produce an automobile that could
be integrated into the new consumer society not as a luxury
item, but as an everyday necessity. Kiyooka clearly appreciated
the bohemian look of the Model T Ford, which he contrasted with
his father's luxury car. He goes on to state the visual characteristics
of the Model T,
I treated it as
my toy, I never washed it. The only work I gave was on the
engine, the engine was kept beautiful. That was more or less
the fashion, a Ford should be dusty, that was the times you
know. You must not think of the Fords of today. The Fords
of the 1920s were entirely different, they were supposed to
be dusty and very useful, but nothing pretty.12
Writing for a Japanese
audience in 1928, Kiyooka asserted that he had driven during
this period "some twenty thousand miles all over the north-eastern
part of the United States."13
In 1927, after graduating
from Cornell University with a B. A. in English literature,
Kiyooka Eiichi prepared
242
to return to his parents' home in Tokyo. Although it would have
been faster to take the transcontinental train to San Francisco,
Kiyooka opted instead for a forty-day adventure motoring and camping
across the United States. As a Japanese visitor, Kiyooka was somewhat
apprehensive about travelling alone. His friend and fellow student
Max Fisch encouraged him to take this trip. Fisch was to be married
that summer in Indianapolis, and he and his fianceé Ruth
Bales eventually decided to accompany Kiyooka across the country
to Max's parents' home in San Francisco. The
trip camping across the country would be their honeymoon. Kiyooka
decided not to return by train to San Francisco, a mode of transportation
he considered boring, "The usual way would have been to take a
train in Ithaca to San Francisco, but going across the country
by train looked like a very stupid thing to do."14
They planned to camp
as they went, and Kiyooka purchased an auto-tent and other supplies
with this end in mind. Autocamping across the country provided
a sense of adventure to early motorists. By 1927, camping vacations
of this kind were a favorite pastime of middle and upper-class
Americans. Autos Across America: A Bibliography of Transcontinental
Automobile Travel, 1903-1940 lists 66 published accounts
of cross-country trips before 1927, suggesting the popularity
of taking these trips as well as writing and reading about them.15
Automobiles freed travellers from the rigid standardization
of railway timetables and established routes, breaking the companies'
monopoly on cross-country tourism. Individual motorists were
able to follow their own inclinations on the road. As Belasco
notes, "Autocamping originally appealed to affluent individualists
for whom the very lack of an infrastructure was its major attraction."16
During the last few
months in Ithaca, Kiyooka took apart and re-assembled the engine
of his Model T; if they had any breakdowns en route, he wanted
to be able to repair it. Belasco mentions the same tendency
in his study of early motorists in Americans on the Road,
"Since most cars--especially the Model
T--were simple enough to be tinkered with, the average motorist
could feel that in case of
243
breakdown he had
at least an even chance of fixing it."17 Kiyooka
believed that an automobile trip across the country, in addition
to being a lot of fun, would show him new insights about America,
a country that he, like many other Japanese, believed was an
advanced democracy and a model for the development of Japan.
Prior to his departure,
Kiyooka wrote to his parents requesting permission to purchase
a new 16mm Kodak movie camera. Eastman Kodak had first marketed
16mm film stock, cameras, and projectors for the amateur market
in 1923. Anticipating the long delay in international mail,
a fact he was familiar with from his seven years in the U. S.,
Kiyooka knew well that he would already have started his trip
before his parents' official response arrived, thereby preventing
them from exerting any effective long distance authority over
his decision. This action enabled Kiyooka to fulfill the traditional
Japanese obligation towards parental authority while simultaneously
demonstrating a more cavalier individualism learned during his
stay in the U. S. Despite his assertiveness, Kiyooka's motives
were good; he wanted to show his mother what the American countryside
looked like. While some Japanese had seen San Francisco or New
York, few had ventured to see the great expanses of the midwestern
and southwestern states. Fortunately for our sake, his parents
didn't have the time to object to his extravagance, and a thirty-minute
16mm record of this remarkable trip still exists. Kiyooka learned
how to make films the same way he learned how to drive; he briefly
consulted a Kodak manual, and a friend showed him how to shoot
his first rolls. This footage may represent the first documentary
filming of America by a Japanese.
The innovations which
made motion pictures available to amateurs like Kiyooka Eiichi
parallel many of the developments that led to the widespread
popularity of the Model T Ford. In 1923, after a long period
of testing and competition between various formats, Eastman
Kodak introduced 16mm equipment, a substandard format that was
accepted by other companies in the industry such as Victor Animatograph
of Davenport, Iowa, and Bell and Howell of Chicago, making personal
movies less expensive and available to large numbers of consumers.
The film stock introduced was reversal film, reducing the costs
of printing stages necessary with negative film. The
film used a cellulose safety-based stock that eliminated the
threat of fire, a notorious problem of nitrate-based film stock.
Because reversal film has finer grain structure than negative,
the smaller gauge significantly reduced the cost of the material
without sacrificing too much of the image quality.18
The smaller format, reversal development, and mass-production
techniques made 16mm approximately one-sixth the cost of comparable
35mm equipment.
Early Kodak cameras
took 100' daylight-loading spools and soon had spring wound
motors so they could be hand-held rather than hand-cranked on
a tripod. At a time when hand-held shooting was comparatively
rare in the film industry, the hand-held quality of Kiyooka's
camerawork is perhaps one of the most distinctive and dynamic
features of his film. The 16mm equipment offered the technical
simplicity that consumers were accustomed to in still photography.
Alan Kattelle notes its widespread popularity, "The 16mm direct
reversal film was enormously successful. Within two years of
its introduction, Kodak processing labs were set up in major
cities across the country."19 Although 16mm
equipment brought moving pictures directly into the hands of
millions more Americans in the 1920s, amateur moviemaking was
still an expensive venture. A 1927 Kodak brochure lists a price
for the Cine-Kodak Model B with a f/3.5mm lens at $100.00. The
camera weighed just five pounds. The Kodascope Model C Projector
cost $60.00. 100' of Cine-Kodak Film, with processing, cost
$6.00. In the early days of 16mm, home moviemaking was a costly
and ambitious endeavor. Kiyooka easily spent more money on his
16mm movie equipment than he did on his second-hand Model T
Ford.
According to his
1976 manuscript, a translation of his published accounts from
1928, the cross-country trip commenced on June 9, 1927, in Ithaca,
New York, with Kiyooka driving alone to catch up with his friends
Ruth and Max who were busy preparing their wedding ceremony
in Winchester, Indiana, at the home of Ruth's family. Kiyooka
rushed through Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana in three days
to arrive in time for the wedding, covering over six hundred
miles at an average speed of 27 miles per hour. There was little
chance of being caught speeding because the Model T Ford didn't
go fast enough to speed and there weren't so many police cars
on the road in those days. On the first day, after a late start,
Kiyooka travelled one hundred miles and--after dining and refueling
in Blossburg, Pennsylvania--spent the night in a hotel in Williamsport.
On the way, and indeed throughout the whole trip, he managed
to keep careful notes in his diaries about the towns through
which he passed, the expenses he paid, and the conversations
he shared. He rose early the next day to make the most of the
daylight hours and drove 230 miles in fourteen and a half hours.
The second night was spent in a hotel in Washington, Pennsylvania,
a small town on the western side of Pittsburgh. Kiyooka didn't
bother to camp yet for he was in a hurry to get to Winchester.
The following morning, he sent a telegram--another recent technological
innovation--via Western Union to alert his friends of his estimated
time of arrival. As Kiyooka's diaries and films suggest, covering
long distances at a consistently high speed was one of the thrills
of early road travel.
After fifteen more
hours on the road and a light meal at a roadside stand near
Springfield, Ohio, Kiyooka arrived at
244
Ruth's parents' home in Winchester, Indiana at ten o'clock on
the evening of June 11, 1927. After the wedding of Max and Ruth
Fisch the following day, the three companions set out for Indianapolis,
where, to their dismay, they had their first breakdown. Eventually,
their cross-country travels took them through Illinois, where
they visited Abraham Lincoln's log cabin in Springfield; Missouri;
Kansas, where the pavement turned into dirt road; Colorado; New
Mexico; Arizona, where they attended a frontier days rodeo; and
finally, California. In San Francisco, Kiyooka
sold his Model T to his friends in exchange for 30 dollars and
some books. After several days of rest and relaxation, he boarded
a steamship bound for Tokyo and carried with him the films and
diaries of his forty day trip across the United States.20
As noted earlier,
Kiyooka's film of the 1927 trip consists of 29:45 minutes of
16mm film. There are roughly 367 individual shots in this footage,
an average shot length of 4.8 seconds. The footage, like most
silent film, was originally shot at sixteen frames per second.
However, because the film was transferred to videotape at eighteen
frames per second, these figures are necessarily approximate.
The rapid shooting style demonstrates the influence of snapshot
photography on the aesthetics of home movies and travelogues.
However, not all of the stylistic features of the footage should
be attributed to intention; the camera may have malfunctioned
in parts and Kiyooka might describe some of these features as
mistakes, "We don't think of the picture taking. We are not
professional picture takers, so when things happen, we forget.
Only a very small part of the drama, really it's impossible."21
The cameraperson, and we know from the images that it wasn't
always Kiyooka who filmed during the trip, commonly took short
bursts of film much like a still photographer, not entirely
aware of how fast these glimpses might go by on the screen.
The footage also appears to have been edited in parts, testifying
both to Kiyooka's ambition as an amateur moviemaker and to the
deleterious effects of time; some of the splices were made simply
to repair broken sprocket holes and the like. Nevertheless the
footage is in surprisingly good condition given its age.
The film begins in
Ithaca as a Model T Ford emerges from a garage in a suburban
home on Elmwood Avenue, located on a hill within walking distance
of Cornell University. Dressed in workman's clothing, Kiyooka
wrestles with the engine of the automobile in broad daylight.
He
245
liked to work outdoors
in the street like this, part of the everyday life of the town.
In the film, Kiyooka includes shots of neighborhood children
playing around him, cross-cutting between
two lines of action, "That was taken as it happened. It was
my dramatic instinct I guess, I just added the children to my
work. I wanted to show the natural scene of my working outdoors
and people passing by. I wanted to be an engineer in the beginning
and I came to the United States with that idea."22
Kiyooka juxtaposes shots of his own work on the engine with
scenes of children playing with a toy wagon, thematically linking
the two actions as leisure activities.
Other automobiles
pass in the background as Kiyooka slides under the car. Several
men appear in this scene, one of whom may be professor Clark
S. Northrup, Kiyooka's host for his seven years in Ithaca. As
is characteristic of home movies in general, the individuals
who appear in these images are part of a network of familial
and close personal relationships. Kiyooka makes little attempt
to record the activities of strangers and those who appear in
his films are usually in the distant background in long shots.
Clearly, Kiyooka's self-image as an engineer brought him into
contact with the engine of the Model T Ford and the Kodak 16mm
camera, although in this case he obviously asked someone to
film these scenes of his work. He was friends with at least
one other Japanese student at Cornell who was making home movies
at the time. Most of this scene is composed of medium shots
which show Kiyooka and the car together although there are occasional
insert shots in close up of the engine and various parts. The
scene ends with several close-up portraits of Kiyooka and his
Japanese friend who smile and make faces for the camera. The
camera is steadily hand-held throughout and moves to follow
action in the frame. Needless to say, the film is in black and
white.
At the outset, Kiyooka
stages scenes of himself working on the car. He removes and
cleans the valves, carburetor, and radiator. Scenes of work
show up rarely in most
246
home movies. Typically,
such amateur footage provides a compendium of pleasurable leisure
activities centered around birthdays, weddings, and other holiday
celebrations. As Richard Chalfen shows
in Snapshot Versions of Life, "Home movies do not record
the reality of everyday life. Instead we find a carefully selected
repertory of highlighted scenes and occurences that a family
is likely to celebrate and wish to remember."23
Kiyooka's footage is exceptional for showing an activity that
many ordinary Americans enjoyed in the 1920s. One of the features
of the Model T most admired by its owners was its relative simplicity.
Automobile owners could tinker with this remarkable new technology
and still hope to understand it. We can see, however, that Kiyooka
working on the car in this fashion was itself a form of leisure
activity, preparation for the adventurous trip across the U.
S. In this case, comparisons with American home movies of the
period would be most instructive, to know whether others made
visual records of these activities. Certainly we know that people
often posed for pictures next to their cars, showing pride of
ownership and class. For Kiyooka, the Model T Ford was not a
necessity, a means for reaching markets as, for example, for
many farmers living in the countryside at the time. It really
didn't provide him with functional transportation at all. The
Model T was primarily a plaything, as he states, "I treated
it as my toy, I never washed it."24 For an
upper-class Japanese man from Tokyo, America in the 1920s was
a playground.
In the film's following
scene, Kiyooka stages his departure from Ithaca. From his third-story
window, Kiyooka throws his clothes down to the front yard. Match-on-action
cuts follow the fall of the clothes to the ground. He then appears
to gather up his clothes and packs them in his steamer trunk
for the trip. We must remember that Kiyooka envisioned his family,
and especially his mother, as the intended audience for his
films. His irreverent behavior again shows a youthful abandonment
of traditional Japanese decorum and social custom. One can imagine
his mother's responses to the images of
his rebelliousness; she was a woman who forbade her son to see
movies and carefully regulated his readings as an adolescent.
According to Kiyooka, his mother had a common upper-class disdain
for the movies, "My mother was a very strict woman. She considered
motion pictures to be a lowdown, undesirable sort of art. No,
she didn't consider it an art either. It was a very popular
entertainment for other people, but not for me. So I never saw
any movies at all, perhaps once or twice I saw motion pictures."25
Apparently Kiyooka had little exposure to movies in his youth;
in 1989, he couldn't recall a single title of a film from the
silent era.
One of the outstanding
features of Kiyooka's home movies is the curious mixture of
the staged and the fortuitous, the arranged and the incidental.
Putting these departure scenes on film took some foresight and
preparation; the technology still required some mechanical competence
to record an image, subjects and makers needed to collaborate
to succeed. The consistent exposure quality of his images, their
careful composition and steady framing, attest to the work of
an ambitious amateur, a dedicated hobbyist who took pride in
his craft. With little knowledge of the movies, Kiyooka transformed
this undesirable art into his own form of expression.
Once the Model T
is packed, Kiyooka climbs in without opening the door, starts
the car, and drives off. A series of shots show the Model T
moving down East Hill towards Ithaca's downtown commercial center.
At a busy intersection, he passes the Rothschild's department
store. The tracks of Ithaca's street cars are visible in the
brick pavement of the main State Street. As he moves out into
the countryside, Kiyooka alternately glances, smiles, waves,
and tips his hat at the camera, saying goodbye to the town where
he had lived for seven years. Again, these elaborately staged
shots suggest that communicating a message and constructing
a narrative was more important to Kiyooka than recording events
as they actually happened. Kiyooka's camera-conscious behavior
tacitly acknowledges this fact.
As Kiyooka moves
out onto the open highway, we get the first shot of the road
from the point-of-view of the driver inside the car. Whoever
was actually shooting the scenes of his departure has presumably
been left behind. The bumpy movement of the camera suggests
the feel of early road travel; even at 27 miles an hour it was
something of a rocky ride. We see the horizon in the distance
as the road opens, the vast fields on either side of the highway
are framed only by the receding telephone poles and wires. These
images document the thrill of movement and the thrill of reproducing
movement through the cinema, one of the main differences between
home movies and snapshot photographs. Advertisers targeted the
reproduction of motion as a selling point over still photography,
"Living movies--full of personal interest--are now taking their
place in the modern homes of the land. Movies--that save for
a lifetime the events of today you want to remember. Not in
motionless fragments, but in moving action exactly as
in life."26 Still photographs, once hailed
as the highpoint of realism, suddenly seemed lacking. Kiyooka
and the Fisches took no still photographs of their trip.
These opening scenes
suggest the centrality of the automobile in the new landscape
the amateur movie camera portrayed. In this sequence, the Model
T Ford itself emerges as the star. In Americans on the Road,
Belasco outlines this pivotal role:
247
Unlike the train--a
huge machine that belonged to a corporation--the car belonged
to the tourist and was in fact the trip's focal point.
In early touring the sights were often just excuses for being
in the car. Autocampers slept in cars, cooked on radiators,
and used running boards as headrests for their autotents.
Since most cars--especially the Model T--were simple enough
to be tinkered with, the average motorist could feel that
in case of breakdown he had at least an even chance of fixing
it.27
Kiyooka's trip across
the country in 1927 confirms many of the previously described
features of early road travel and demonstrates the extent to
which he had adopted distinctly American material culture and
technology. Kiyooka noted in his diaries that automobile travel
was less expensive than travel by train:
According to my
record, for the 1670 miles between Ithaca and Lawrence, the
expenditure on gasoline and oil had been $21.71. If I had
come this distance by railway, the ticket alone would have
cost at least $70, and that for one person only. People said
that it was much cheaper to be travelling by car than living
in a house, because there would be no rent to pay and considering
food expenses to be about the same, the fuel expenses were
negligible.28
At the time, few
other countries had so thoroughly integrated the automobile
into the fabric of everyday life. James Flink argues, "With
the advent of the Model T and improved roads, the automobile
outing and the automobile vacation became middle-class institutions."29
Although Kiyooka returned to live in Japan in 1927, he never
vacationed by car there, nor did he ever go camping in his own
country, "Japan is not quite right for camping. It's a very
moist place and I don't think it's comfortable to sleep outdoors
there. I never tried."30 Back in Japan, Kiyooka
followed the norms of Japanese culture.
These opening scenes
demonstrate Kiyooka's intense interest in the automobile; his
experiences autocamping across the country and his amateur moviemaking
show his knowledge of "things western." Kiyooka's fascination
with the mechanics of the Model T Ford didn't end with the engine.
The sleeping arrangements for the three campers necessitated
that Kiyooka sleep in the car while the newlyweds shared a cot
inside the autotent, which was
248
attached at an incline to the roof of the car. Together with a
garage mechanic, Kiyooka modified the interior of the automobile
to make it as comfortable as possible:
The Fisch couple
had a bed, a folding bed, you know, with the tent over it.
One end of the tent was tied to the car. That was their quarters
at night and I slept inside the car. That was my invention.
Very soon after I found that some cars were made that way.
Part of the front seat was hinged and
made to fall backwards. The back of the front seat is hinged.
I had the garageman saw down both sides of the front seat
and add hinges to the bottom, so that the back of the front
seat will fall backwards and that will make front, middle,
and rear cushions. All three make a nice bed. Well, I won't
say nice--it was very bumpy--but it fitted my back very nicely.31
Kiyooka made the
Model T Ford to his own size, even going so far as to write,
"The Model T Ford seemed to have been custom built to fit my
body."32 Kiyooka identified with the car as
an extension of the human body, a self-moving machine.
The centrality of
the Model T Ford in this newly evolving social landscape appears
in manifold other ways in Kiyooka's films and the diaries. The
performance of the car and the condition of the roads provided
a forum for social exchange between travellers. Lacking a tourist
infrastructure, travellers had to rely on word of mouth about
routes to follow and they frequently aided one another in case
of car trouble. On June 17, ten miles west of Columbia, Missouri,
Kiyooka's Model T broke down after just eight days on the road.
Judging from the narrative interest devoted to this incident,
the breakdown was one of the more memorable occasions of the
trip. Professor Kiyooka took much pleasure in re-telling the
story of this breakdown sixty-two years later. His 1976 manuscript
devotes several pages to describing this event:
249
We were running
along a fine concrete road at our usual 27 miles an hour.
The engine suddenly raced up and the car began slowing down.
The clutch pedal and the brake seemed to have gone dead. The
car coasted along a hundred yards out of control. Then a scraping
sound and the car fell upon its belly as the left rear wheel
came off and went rolling and wabbling ahead of us till it
fell into the ditch. We stopped after skidding ten yards.
Now that we knew what was the matter, we in unison broke out
laughing. But our laughing did not last long as we realized
how far we had come from the last garage we passed on the
roadside. It was a cloudy day, and it was beginning to rain
lightly. We were helpless.
Just at that moment,
a farmer leading a cow came across the field laughing. "Just
as I was watching your car," he said between his laughter,
"the rear wheel began to slide out. The axle stretched further
and further out, and just as I yelled, 'That wheel's coming
off,' Plump! it popped off. It was the funniest sight I've
ever seen."
He repeated it
many times over with lively gestures. He laughed and laughed
till he was literally doubling over himself. We watched him
dumbfounded. After a while, the farmer
began to say he would go and get help for us at a garage just
round the corner, and he ran off leading his cow, singing
to himself. In a few minutes, he was back in a truck with
the garage man, still repeating his narration with gestures.33
Astonishingly, Kiyooka
had the presence of mind to remember to film this mechanical
breakdown. The shots are uncharacteristically under-exposed,
suggesting the inadequacy of the light from the overcast cloudy
sky and perhaps a certain hastiness in Kiyooka's preparation
to film. The people in the images appear completely oblivious
to the presence of the camera, an interesting fact of Kiyooka's
shooting style which suggests a more documentary emphasis than
typical home movies. In home movies, the act of shooting often
takes precedence over whatever else may be happening and, as
a result, people pose and act specifically for the camera. In
this sequence, we see three men lifting the car off of its broken
axle. The ground is streaked with rain as Ruth watches in the
background. They walk alongside the Model T as another automobile
pulls it towards the garage. Events such as these formed some
of the excitement for early automobile travellers and provided
no small part of the stories they would later tell and of the
films they would later show about their adventures on the road.
Again, since this was a leisurely vacation, all aspects of the
trip fueled Kiyooka's imagination and his sense of adventure.
As Belasco notes, "Bad weather, muddy roads, washouts, a fellow
motorist stranded ahead were unpredictable events that intervened
and forced even the most scheduled tourist to stop, take a breather,
meet fellow tourists, and take in the view."34
Waylaid by the breakdown, Kiyooka and the Fisches spent the
night in the upstairs room of the local general store, their
camping plans still thwarted. This housing arrangement may be
seen as an improvised hotel to host tourists before the development
of roadside motels. For nine dollars, the local garage mechanic
fixed the axle, and the next day they set out towards Lawrence,
Kansas.
Kiyooka documented
how the automobile was changing the shape of the American landscape.
Throughout his film, he returns to travelling shots taken from
the car, hurtling past farmlands, bridges, rivers, and towns,
providing the narrative momentum of the journey west. In a brief
sequence somewhere in Kansas, a highway marker appears in several
frames, indicating route 40, the celebrated Lincoln highway.
We see a shot of a road sign boasting of "Red Crown Gasoline."
Kiyooka noticed how road signs appeared well in advance of the
stations themselves, giving the motorist enough time to slow
down. He described this phenomenon for his Japanese readers
in 1928:
This
icecream stand corresponds to what we call the tea stall in
Japan. The only curious thing about it was that its sign stood
a quarter of a mile away from the stand. This was from necessity
for stopping a car that came at forty miles an hour. This
kind of eating places and gasoline stations by the roadside
were a new development of very recent years since the motor
trips became an everyday affair.35
Kiyooka delineates
a landscape recently made for the automobile. In a two-shot
sequence, he attempts to convey the look of this autoscape.
First we see the road sign passing by, then we pass by a gas
station. Presumably, when Kiyooka showed the film to family
and friends, he provided just this kind of interpretive commentary
on the landscape so different from that of Japan. Home movies
and travelogues of this nature are typically accompanied during
projection by an explanatory voice-over narration by the filmmaker.
Here, as elsewhere in his writings and films, Kiyooka himself
stands as a mediator, a translator between American and Japanese
culture. Kiyooka might have sought a wider audience for his
films than just his family and friends if a system of 16mm travelogue
distribution had been in place in Japan in the 1920s. Clearly
it was easier to find a publisher for a written account for
a general audience.
The structure and
condition of the roads reappear throughout the films and diaries.
We see horse-drawn carriages sloshing through the muddy main
street of a town
250
that may be Garden City, Kansas, "Yes, Kansas
was an interesting state. Interesting that the pavement on the
highway stopped about halfway through Kansas. We went across one
village and the pavement stopped, and now the dirt road."36
The following sequence taken from the inside of the moving Model
T shows what the unpaved roads west of Topeka, Kansas were really
like. The camera jerks from side to side violently as the car
plows ahead through a thin muddy trail with furrowed fields on
either side. It looks like they're driving in the middle of a
farm. Then we see the Model T stuck in several feet of mud; Max,
Ruth, and an unidentified motorist survey the damage. Then, the
other motorist's car tows the Model T out of the mud, a scene
that appears to have occurred with some regularity during the
trip. Kiyooka delighted in telling the stories of the mud holes
of the western states:
The rest of the
road might be quite dry, but once in awhile there's a small
patch of mud. Anyway, it's a small area that's very muddy
and the cars will get stuck in it. The first time we ran into
this mud hole, we didn't know anything about it, and we wondered
whether we could go beyond that point or not. Perhaps the
unpaved road would last until we got to California. So we
were really concerned about whether we could go or not. The
mud hole we found was just a small area, maybe thirty feet
across, and so if you passed that mud hole you are on dry
ground again. The best way was to run into the mud hole and
get stuck and wait until another car comes in the other direction.
They would stop before running into the mud hole. We'd ask
them to pull us out and we'd throw them a rope or something.
When you get out of the car you have to be ready to walk in
the mud to throw them a rope. They tie the rope to the car
and pull us out and we say thank you and go on. Then this
man who helped us out goes into the mud hole and waits for
another car to come along to pull him out. When you get used
to it, it isn't too bad if you take it in the right spirit.37
251
Kiyooka indicates the leisurely tempo of early road travel and
the development of a motorist's etiquette. His decision to film
this event shows both his interest in the rough "untamed" landscape
of the west and the adventures and photo opportunities afforded
by automobile travel. Max Fisch also pointed out some of these
characteristics of early road travel, "In
the west, you couldn't tell by the look of the road ahead what
the damn road was going to look like when you got beyond anything
you could now see. There just wasn't a national road system with
a set of standards that required the states to build roads and
keep them in repair."38 In fact, the first signs
of a federal highway system only began appearing in the late 1920s.
The landscape of
the prairie states captured Kiyooka's imagination. He preferred
long shots to take in these views, although he was not adverse
to positioning objects in the foreground and middleground as
well. From a fixed camera position, we see Max, Ruth, and Kiyooka
unpacking their lunch along a roadside ditch. The great depth
of field shows the vast expanse of the horizon beyond them.
Of these roadside picnics, Kiyooka stated, "There was no point
in going anywhere else. Of course, we would look for shade,
a tree, or something. But in the prairie, in the movie, there
was no shade within sight, no tree within sight, so we had to
just sit out in the open. And that's why I took a picture of
it, it was so unique, you know, having lunch like that out in
the open."39 Kiyooka even devised a characteristic
shooting style to encompass the panoramas he saw and wanted
to record. He offers several 360° pans of the landscape, constructed
of multiple shots. The spring wound motor of his Cine-Kodak
couldn't take shots longer than twenty seconds, so he would
pan across part of the landscape, stop to rewind the motor,
and then begin the pan at the point where the last shot ended.
In each case, then, there is a brief jump cut, a practice which
nevertheless allowed Kiyooka to piece together a spatially continuous
scene, representing the open vistas before him.
Another picnic scene
shows Ruth and Max eating by a fence in the shade of the Model
T. Then, with Max taking his turn behind the camera, we see
Kiyooka and Ruth packing the car after their meal. This exchange
of the camera seems to take place so that everyone will appear
in the footage. They don't clown for the camera as people in
home movies often do but rather go about
their activities with industrious indifference. The flat grasslands
of the prairie were unlike any landscape Kiyooka had ever seen,
"Prairie is just so wide open, you know, nothing higher than
yourself. If you stand up you are the tallest thing within sight."40
In the film, Kiyooka offers a series of lovely portraits of
his friends in the prairie landscape, silhouetted against the
setting sun on the horizon. Then, Ruth takes the camera and
frames Max and Kiyooka against the horizon, where Kiyooka and
Max are clearly the tallest things within sight. This day-to-night
structure punctuates the narrative by appearing halfway through
the film and then again in the very last shot, the setting sun
on the Pacific ocean as the ship carries Kiyooka homeward.
A later picnic scene
brought out some of the characteristics of home movies, especially
their function as memory devices. Max, Ruth, and Kiyooka are
having breakfast along the riverbed of the Rio Grande in a long
shot taken from a fixed angle. Kiyooka follows this establishing
shot with several delightful close-ups of Max, Ruth, and the
campfire they are tending. There are very few close-ups throughout
this film; the vast majority of shots are medium and long shots.
Upon seeing these images sixty-two years after they were taken,
Max said, "That's better, I've been wishing the pictures of
Ruth were clearer."41 In 1974, Ruth Bales
Fisch died. Over time, the value of the images shifted. What
was filmed is not necessarily what one wishes, in retrospect,
had been filmed. Memories, too, fade and wear away. Max, whose
own recollections of the trip were a poignant reminder of the
frailty of human memory, was no doubt struck with the vibrant
images of Ruth smiling that morning, camping on the riverbed
on their honeymoon trip across the country.
On their automobile
trip, Kiyooka and the Fisches experienced the entire range of
camping arrangements then available, from roadside autotent
camping, free municipal autocamps, and relatively expensive
cabin camps. In these campgrounds, which Kiyooka never filmed,
the travellers met and shared stories and food with others like
themselves. Kiyooka described these campgrounds in the rhetoric
of democratic populism:
The camps are the
most interesting places in the country, for all manner of
people come together to spend a night together and part the
next morning to all different destinations. Some would be
driving a fine car with expensive camping equipment; some
would be nursing and coaxing his rickety old car from stalling;
some are well-to-do men and their families; some are almost
pennyless vagabonds. Some are laborers looking for jobs; there
may be a man moving to another town with all his big family
and all his possessions piled high on his truck; he may be
carrying his dogs, cats and even chickens.
All these people
draw water from the same source, talk together while they
cook. They exchange informations on the best road to take
and gossip all about the happenings on the road. In these
camps at least, there is not discrimation between rich or
poor, coarse or cultured. When someone's engine fails
252
to
start or his cooking range goes out of order, all the campers
take interest and help.42
Earlier Japanese
visitors to the United States had spoken of the country in similar
terms. According to Tadashi Aruga, the Japanese delegates of
the first mission to the U. S. in 1860 noted the same informality
between individuals and different social classes, "Compared
with the highly stratified, etiquette-ridden Japanese society,
the republican nation was strikingly informal and devoid of
class and status distinctions. To the conservative Muragaki,
these American characteristics were distasteful. Some samurai
of lower status, however, viewed the same characteristics with
favor."43 Travelling across the country sixty-seven
years after the first Japanese mission, Kiyooka admired many
of the same features in the American social landscape.
Aruga also notes
that although the members of the first mission visited in 1860,
they failed to realize that slavery was the critical issue dividing
the nation. Kiyooka's written account of the 1920s speaks explicitly
of his encounter with segregation and racism in restaurants
and hotels. Reluctant to say anything unpleasant about America
during the interviews, our persistent questions elicited this
response from Kiyooka, "This is my first experience of Americans
trying to find something to make themselves look bad."44
Reluctantly, Kiyooka described his experiences in St. Louis,
"I saw the signs at a small restaurant, dining room, and then
on each side a little note saying, 'Colored People's Eating
Place,' with an arrow pointing to the kitchen. At that restaurant,
white people and negroes were not supposed to eat in the same
rooms together. I just wondered what door I should enter. Later,
I found that we foreigners are taken into the white people's
room."45 As a Japanese man, Kiyooka transgressed
rigid racial boundaries between whites and blacks. Although
he wrote about these events and remembered them well, Kiyooka
did not film anything remotely associated with the issue of
racism, perhaps a feature of the tendency of home movie makers
to
253
avoid unpleasant subject matter. There can be little doubt that
Kiyooka's cross-country trip avoided the southern United States
because of Jim Crow laws in effect in the 1920s, laws that might
have applied to him. As a Japanese, he was apprehensive about
travelling in the south. At the same time, we should also remember
that the main routes were east-west and going south would have
taken him far out of his way.
Throughout their
trip, Kiyooka and the Fisches appear surprisingly well dressed
for the occasion, in knickers, high socks, and motoring caps.
Max even sports a striped tie in several scenes.
When we mentioned this to Professor Fisch, he reminded us that
the images were not unmediated views of actuality, "Sometimes
we were dressing for the films. We had the clothes with us and
if we wanted to take a picture in which we would look well cared
for, we might dress up a little."46 Like photographs,
films are invested with specific views of the world, delicately
balanced between construction and recording. The travellers
wanted to present dapper, sporting, and adventurous images of
themselves as campers. Kiyooka, however, does not limit himself
to reproducing views of himself in the landscape. Whereas most
home movies and travelogues insist upon the travellers' presence
in every scene, Kiyooka and his friends are often content to
remain behind the camera, focusing on the lay of the land. By
placing so much emphasis on the countryside and the material
culture of the United States, Kiyooka shows that much of what
interested him was happening out there in the landscape. Throughout
the film, he includes shots of various farm animals, water pumps,
wells, and wagons.
There are several
points in the trip where Kiyooka's various narrative accounts
implicitly contradict one another. Shortly after he leaves Ithaca,
the film cuts to scenes of bears pacing around and seals swimming
in an unmarked zoo. In the 1989 interviews, Kiyooka suggested
that it might be the Cleveland Zoo. However, his 1976 manuscript
shows no record of a trip to any zoos east of Indianapolis and
in fact, at the trip's outset, his written itinerary shows that
he was speeding to attend his friends' wedding in Winchester,
Indiana and had no time for sightseeing. To some extent, all
of the departure footage belies the feeling of haste conveyed
in his written account. Amateur moviemaking was a leisurely
process that took time. The high quality of most of Kiyooka's
footage suggests that he put some care and planning into making
these images. It is entirely possible that the opening footage
of his departure was filmed some time before he actually started
out on the trip. Likewise, I believe that these scenes of the
zoo were spliced in later to provide a visual contrast with
the repetitive driving scenes. Perhaps they were taken during
a different trip to Cleveland, although it is possible that
he didn't write about this visit in his published account because
it contradicted the textual suspense of his race against the
clock to Winchester for the wedding.
This perspective
implies, however, that the movie footage provides a more accurate
account of the trip, an assumption that we cannot make. It seems
more likely that these shots, whose density and contrast vary
with those before and after, were added at a later date, although
Kiyooka himself no longer remembers for sure. Kiyooka's inability
to recall indicates how home movies are specifically
linked to memory, as Chris Musello notes in a study of family
photography, "Because the interpretations are based in processes
of recall, over time the power and value of these images may
evolve and change or even be lost as memory decays. Thus photograph
collections as documentary resources are perhaps more closely
associated with an oral rather than a written tradition."47
In any case, we see shots of bears pacing back and forth in
carefully reconstructed natural environments, on display for
early tourists and city dwellers. As well as the bears, we see
several shots of a man feeding seals, further evidence of the
animal world's increasing dependence on its human brethren.
This domestication
of the natural suggests a parallel for the experiences of the
wild west that cross-country tourism offered. The tamed natural
world, no longer a threat to human inhabitation, became a curiosity
for sightseers. These shots of the zoo, beautifully composed
and exposed with the bears prominently displayed in the foreground,
contrast well with later shots of uncaged bears encountered
"in a California forest."48 The uncaged bears
lurk in the distance in hastily composed and poorly exposed
views. They are partially obscured by the natural environment
and are not easily available for amateur moviemakers to film.
In the zoo, the animals exist to be seen and photographed. These
insights may reinforce Dean MacCannell's thesis in The Tourist
that modern industrial society solidifies its triumph over earlier
social forms through the preservation and transformation of
lingering artifacts into tourist attractions.49
Kiyooka's later encounters with Navajo Indians and Spanish-style
architecture in the southwest suggest a similar analysis.
Kiyooka devotes a
considerable amount of footage to the architecture of the southwest.
Their cross-country trip from Ithaca to San Francisco detoured
through the southwest, especially New Mexico, because Kiyooka
and the Fisches were fascinated by the Indian and Spanish influences
in the region. In the 1920s, a vogue developed for the culture
of the southwest, as artists such as Georgia O'Keeffe and others
explored native themes and styles in their work. Kiyooka wrote,
"Naturally many artists had migrated here and there was an artists'
quarter at one end of the town. Also there was a very interesting
art museum exhibiting both purely Indian arts, those of the
old Span-
254
ish missions,
and of contemporary artists."50 These regional
differences were a major novelty for Kiyooka and provided one
of the main motivations for the trip, "American culture, the
usual American culture is more or less familiar in Tokyo and
Japanese towns, and so it isn't anything too different or too
new for us. But those Spanish-style houses and shrines are interesting."51
Repeatedly the two friends returned to descriptions of this
region in their stories of the 1927 trip. As Earl Pomeroy suggests
in In Search of the Golden West, the mythology and exoticism
of the west provided a major attraction for tourism, "Perhaps
the most striking aspect of the changing attitudes towards nature
was the new vogue of the Southwestern desert that had developed
since the 1890s and reached spectacular dimensions in the thirties."52
With his friends
Max Fisch and Ruth Bales, Kiyooka drove across the United States
in his Model T Ford, camping along the way. With a Cine-Kodak
camera in tow, he saw the Rocky mountains, a rodeo, the Grand
Canyon, and the great plains. By and large, these travellers
avoided big cities, preferring the great outdoors. For over
forty days, Kiyooka slept in the front seat of his mass-produced
Model T, tailored to his own specifications. In St. Louis, although
he ate in segregated restaurants--where his own place was uncertain--his
faith in American democracy remained unshaken, "After this trip
I decided that Americans were very kind and sympathetic. They
were all good natured. During this trip of about forty days,
there was not one instance when I heard unpleasant language."53
He identified with white middle-class Americans and saw the
United States as a model for the future development of Japan.
The trip confirmed
Kiyooka's earlier impressions of America, "In Japan in my time--in
my time meaning in my childhood--we heard all the good things
about America."54 Kiyooka's films and diaries
embrace a popular image of America, a great landscape that he
saw in the process of becoming a nation. Kiyooka recorded the
255
complaints of an
American archaeologist encountered in New
Mexico, "Rich Americans were willing to give money to all the
studies of things far away from home, but how much would they
give to the excavation of their homeland? Men like Mr. Halseth
were always hard up raising money for study and for digging.
Well, Americans at that time had so little interest in their
own history and culture."55 Like many Americans,
Kiyooka embraced new mass-produced technologies that changed
the way the social landscape was used and represented. He set
out on his journey to learn from his travels, record them, and
share them with his family, friends, and compatriots in Japan.
Kiyooka Eiichi never
became an engineer. Nor did his filmmaking activities ever extend
beyond that of the amateur home movie maker. In the 1930s, during
a time of increasing militarism and anti-American sentiment
in Japan, Kiyooka worked translating into English the autobiography
of his illustrious grandfather, Fukuzawa, to celebrate the 100th
anniversary of his birth. The Autobiography of Fukuzawa,
a work describing a lifetime of engagement with the culture
of the western world--written in a form commensurate with enlightenment
individualism--appeared in English, translated by Kiyooka, in
1934. Fukuzawa's life, from 1835 to 1901, spanned the period
of Japan's modernization along western lines, "This Fukuzawa
was a rather unique kind of person who was born in the feudal
age--Japan was under the Shogun's rule and was really a feudal
society--but Fukuzawa was a very unique and free-minded person
who was trying to find something new all the time."56
Kiyooka's translation made the story of Fukuzawa, the great
Japanese promoter of western ideas, available to western readers
and marked the beginning of Kiyooka's career as a translator
of his grandfather's works, a further extension of Kiyooka's
own engagement with the culture of the United States and the
western world.
Notes
1. Jeffrey
K. Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi and Maxwell Fisch,"
(Unpublished, 1989), 22. (back)
2. Kenneth
J. Ruoff, "The Making of a Moderate in Prewar Japan: Kiyooka
Eiichi," (Unpublished B. A. thesis, Department of Asian Studies,
Harvard University, 1989), 44. (back)
3. Warren
Belasco, Americans on the Road: From Autocamp to Motel, 1910-1945
(Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1979), 17. (back)
4. Belasco,
Americans on the Road, 72. (back)
5. Tad
Burness, Cars of the Early Twenties (Philadelphia, PA:
Chilton Book Company,1968), 109. (back)
6. Tadashi
Aruga, "The First Japanese Mission to the United States--1860,"
in Abroad in America: Visitors to the New Nation, 1776-1914,
ed. Mark Pachter (Reading, MA: Addison Wesley Publishing Co.
in Association With the Smithsonian Institution, 1976), 143-4.
(back)
7. K.
Ruoff, "The Making of a Moderate," 12-19. (back)
8. Ibid.,
28. (back)
9. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 8. (back)
10. Ibid.,
7. (back)
11. Ibid.
(back)
12. Ibid.
(back)
13. Kiyooka
Eiichi, "Across the United States in a Model T Ford--1927,"
(Unpublished, 1976), 2. (back)
14. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 5. (back)
15. Carey
S. Bliss, Autos Across America: A Bibliography of Transcontinental
Automobile Travel, 1903-1940 (New Haven, CN: Jenkins and
Reese Companies, 1982). (back)
16. Belasco,
Americans on the Road, 7. (back)
17. Ibid.,
35. (back)
18. Glenn
E. Matthews and Raife G. Tarkington, "Early History of Amateur
Motion Picture Film," in A Technological History of Motion
Pictures and Television, ed. Raymond Fielding (Berkeley,
CA: University of California Press, 1967), 140. (back)
19. Alan
D. Kattelle, "The Evolution of Amateur Motion Picture Equipment,
1895-1965," Journal of Film and Video 38, no. 3-4 (Summer-Fall
1986): 51. (back)
20. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 71. (back)
21. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 18. (back)
22. Ibid.,
19. (back)
23. Richard
Chalfen, Snapshot Versions of Life (Bowling Green, OH:
Bowling Green State University Press, 1987), 64. (back)
24. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 7. (back)
25. Ibid.,
8. (back)
26. Bell
and Howell Corporation, "Bell and Howell Advertising Brochure,"
(Chicago, IL, 1927), 3. (back)
27. Belasco,
Americans on the Road, 35.(back)
28. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 18. (back)
29. James
J. Flink, The Automotive Age (Cambridge, MA: The MIT
Press, 1988), 167. (back)
30. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 18. (back)
31. Ibid.,
9. (back)
32. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 3. (back)
33. Ibid.,
13-14. (back)
34. Belasco,
Americans on the Road, 22. (back)
35. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 8. (back)
36. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 8. (back)
37. Ibid.,
22-3. (back)
38. Ibid.,
22. (back)
39. Ibid.,
23. (back)
40. Ibid.,
11. (back)
41. Ibid.,
16. (back)
42. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 18-19. (back)
43. Aruga,
"The First Japanese Mission to the United States," 140. (back)
44. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 12. (back)
45. Ibid.
(back)
46. Ibid.,
3. (back)
47. Chris
Musello, "Studying the Home Mode: An Exploration of Family Photography
and Visual Communication," Studies in Visual Communication
6, no. 1 (Spring 1980), 40. (back)
256
48. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 70. (back)
49. Dean
MacCannell, The Tourist: A New Theory of the Leisure Class
(New York: Schocken Books, 1976), 8. (back)
50. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 44. (back)
51. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 12. (back)
52. Earl
Pomeroy, In Search of the Golden West: The Tourist in Western
America (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1957), 158. (back)
53. K.
Ruoff, "The Making of a Moderate in Prewar Japan," 44-5. (back)
54. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 13. (back)
55. Kiyooka,
"Across the United States in a Model T Ford," 52. (back)
56. J.
Ruoff, "Interviews With Kiyooka Eiichi," 24. (back)
|