What is Global History?
"...in my memory, the book the outline of history was first published in 1919, but in your book is "outline of history, first published in 1901" (P1). Is it a misunderstanding of mine or a misprint of the book?" (August 30, 2008)
I appreciate Liu's courtly suggestion that he might have misread the characters 220.127.116.11 in the text or that it could have been a simple misprint. But the appalling error "1901" of the date of publication is right in the text of What is Global History?, and not just once --it is first invoked on p.1, then comes back on p.5, and is implied on p.2, if not elsewhere. While writing What is Global History, I had a copy of the 1921 edition of The Outline of History on my desk, and I evidently at some point miswrote the publication of date as 1901. Then, I clearly began to believe it in some autonomic way, and incorporated it into my subsequent comments. Despite that, I had the correct publication dates in the notes and bibliography (and the bibliographical entry, in this case, was actually written before the text). I read the manuscript many times, read the proofs, and even read the book after it came out without noticing what I had written in this detail. This is a very eerie experience, realizing in retrospect that I never saw what I had really written, but only saw what I knew I should have written. I have had this experience many times, and fear I wil have it many more.
But wait, there's more.
Liu, remember, stated that the first date of publication of Outline of History was 1919. That is
correct in a way, though it is rarely cited. Wikipedia gets the date wrong (as of August 30, 2008) in its article on Wells himself, but gets it right in
its article on The Outline of
History. This is one of those situations in which a bit of ambiguity can be tolerated. The first
publication of the book was as a serial, published every two weeks in 24 parts, starting in 1919 and
ending in 1920 (which is also an acceptable citation date). The original title was The outline of history, being a plain history of life and
mankind. Written with the advice and editorial help of Ernest Barker [and others], a title that
Wells clearly felt dissatisfied with, probably for several reasons, afterward. When the book was
reprinted by MacMillan in 1920 and 1921, the subtitle was changed to ...written with the advice
and editorial help of Mr. Ernest Barker, Sir H. H. Johnston, Sir E. Ray Lankester, and Professor
Gilbert Murray, and illustrated by J. F. Horrabin. A publication date of anything from 1919 to
1921 is clearly acceptable for Outline, but "1901" is at least a digit off from any of the
correct dates. I have alerted Polity Press to the error, and am hoping it can be corrected soon in
subsequent printings of the book.
And yes, the Dartmouth rare book room has its own copy of the original 1919-1920 printing of Outline. I've probably passed it a time or two, thinking of something else.
Wells' lecture "Discovery of the future" was published in New York in 1913, ironically only twelve years after he had published Outline of History in the imaginary world of What is Global History?, discovering the future of the book's publication in our dimension in 1919.
There is another known typo on the original What is Global History?, subsequently corrected: Charles Sumner Graham on p.35 should be Charles Graham Sumner.