| On Doctoring MEDLINE searches, with reference librarian comments |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
The question was
"How does glucophage affect the metabolism of
Diabetes Type II patients?"1 : exp *Metformin/me,tu [Metabolism, Therapeutic Use] {168}
2 : exp *Diabetes mellitus, non-insulin-dependent/th [Therapy] {427}
3 : 1 and 2 {3}
4 : limit 3 to (local holdings and human and english language) {2}
5 : 1 {168}
6 : limit 5 to (local holdings and human and english language) {97}
7 : exp *Diabetes mellitus, non-insulin-dependent/th [Therapy] {427}
8 : 1 and 6 {97}
9 : 6 and 7 {2}
10 : from 9 keep 1-2 {2}
11 : from 9 keep 1-2 2
Reference Librarian comments
Nice work. You obviously "get it." I have only one bit of advice.
"Therapy" as a subheading does not mean, nor does it include the
concept "Drug Therapy." Hence, I think set#2 is just not big
enough. I think you should have done this: exp *diabetes
mellitus, non-insulin-dependent/dt [Drug Therapy]Just for fun, I did the search also. I used a few more subheadings
with set 1 and I decided to let set #2 get as big as possible (taking
ALL subheadings, not just Drug Therapy) -- and then I whittled it
down with various limits. Finally, I thought a REVIEW article would
be nice. Anyway, it's just another approach.Here's the strategy I used, and the references gotten in the last set
I copied (in case you're interested) at the very bottom of this
message.
1 :
exp *Metformin/me,ae,po,to,tu,ct [Metabolism, Adverse
Effects, Poisoning, Toxicity, Therapeutic Use,
Contraindications]
{226}
2 :
exp *diabetes mellitus, non-insulin-dependent/
{9368}
3 :
1 and 2
{132}
4 :
limit 3 to (human and english language)
{113}
5 :
limit 4 to review articles
{15}
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |